Taylor Swift's Lover feels like a step back to her more carefree, pop-driven roots, but with a noticeable shift in tone. The album leans heavily on soft, pastel vibes and romantic themes, which at times come across as overly sugary or saccharine. While tracks like “ME!” and “You Need To Calm Down” are catchy, they lack the cleverness or emotional depth of her earlier hits. The record’s upbeat, almost bubblegum pop sound fails to convey the maturity Swift has developed in her storytelling; Lover sounds like a collection of 1989 outtakes.

That said, the album has its moments. “The Archer” is a standout, with introspective lyrics and a haunting, atmospheric production that shows off Swift’s ability to dive deep into her vulnerabilities despite the song's surface-level lyricism. Still, the album as a whole can feel a little safe and repetitive, as if it’s trying too hard to blend nostalgia with mainstream appeal. Fans of Swift’s lighter, more romantic side will find plenty to enjoy, but those hoping for another 1989 or Red might be left wanting more.

Favorite song: "Afterglow"